Wooden pretty much as good as Soto? Time to ditch Semien? Do not be shocked

Every week in MLB is its personal story — filled with surprises, each optimistic and detrimental — and fantasy managers should determine what to consider and what to not consider transferring ahead. Maybe we can assist. If any of those ideas come true… do not be shocked!

Washington Nationals OF James Wooden was imagined to emerge as a terrific fantasy choice this season, his first full marketing campaign within the main leagues. Because of this he was a top-50 decide in additional than 1,500 preseason NFBC drafts (a roto/classes format). Based mostly on Wooden’s manufacturing all through the minor leagues and in 79 video games as a rookie, many anticipated not less than 20 house runs and 20 stolen bases from the imposing, 6-foot-7 participant in 2025.

Do not be shocked … if Wooden turns into a top-10 fantasy OF, identical to the $765-million man who used to play in Washington

To be clear, I am speaking about roto codecs, and never factors leagues the place New York Mets OF Juan Soto dominates attributable to his innate capability to attract walks. In roto, nonetheless, whereas few fairly might make the leap to decide on Wooden over Soto, Wooden’s stolen base upside — whereas Soto steals few bases — turns into an necessary differentiator. Plus, Wooden attracts fairly a couple of walks himself. The 22-year-old nonetheless wants to enhance on a number of issues, however the potential for fantasy stardom is kind of clear.

Whereas we knew Wooden was an intriguing prospect when the Nationals extracted him (together with LHP MacKenzie Gore, SS CJ Abrams and others) for generational expertise Soto on the 2022 commerce deadline, there have been no ensures he would develop on this path. Wooden struck out in 33.7% of his at-bats at Double-A Harrisburg, his low contact price considerably masked by his potential in different areas. Wooden hit solely .248. Nonetheless, he vastly improved his self-discipline at Triple-A Rochester final season and rapidly turned a fantasy difference-maker for the Nationals, offering 9 house runs and 14 steals in 336 PA

This season, over 12 video games and 50 PA hitting largely within the No. 2 spot versus right-handed pitching, Wooden is exhibiting combined indicators. The excellent news is that Wooden has 4 house runs, three versus left-handed pitching. Final season, Wooden slugged solely .339 off lefties, together with solely considered one of his 9 house runs.

This season, he’s slugging 1.000 in 20 PA towards lefties — and we all know he can hit right-handers, posting an .858 OPS final season. Total, Wooden boasts a 14% stroll price and .325 remoted energy. These are nice indicators. Nonetheless, few can thrive with a 73.1% floor ball price (second in MLB) and a 34% strikeout price is a bummer, too. Nonetheless, a 30-HR, 25-SB choice is feasible. It is not Soto-level, however it’s noteworthy.

It might appear foolish to check Soto, with an almost 37 bWAR by means of seven seasons and nicely on his solution to the Corridor of Fame, with a youthful participant who has but to even qualify for the batting title and went exterior the highest 100 picks in ESPN factors codecs, however we’re speaking about roto/class fantasy leagues right here. Wooden appears to be like able to nice issues if he could make extra contact, hit extra fly balls and steal bases.

It stays shocking that Wooden stays out there in 25% of ESPN normal leagues. He’s a possible constructing block in roto, and nonetheless underrated in factors codecs. No, he is not the four-category dynamo that Soto is, however few gamers are. Wooden ought to present glorious worth, and fantasy managers could discover time is working out to capitalize.

Do not be shocked … if Athletics SS Jacob Wilson is the AL’s model of San Diego Padres 1B/2B Luis Arraez

Right here is one other relative comparability between a veteran supplier and an unestablished teenager. Everyone knows how Arraez helps fantasy managers, as he has earned three consecutive batting titles and his profession contact price is 92.7% — a ridiculous determine harking back to soft-hitting, bunt-first, center infielders from a number of generations in the past. Arraez just isn’t as helpful in roto leagues, the place the batting common stands for his essential contribution. He is by no means hit greater than 10 house runs, stolen 10 bases or scored 90 runs in a season. Arraez completed 2024 because the No. 29 ESPN points-league hitter, however he was the No. 49 hitter on the Participant Rater (roto).

Wilson, 23, is in his first full season and he’s exhibiting Arraez-like tendencies, for positive. Getting into Thursday, Wilson was hitting .396 with a 95.8% contact price. He has but to attract a stroll and he has struck out solely twice (each in the identical recreation) over his 13 video games and 48 PA.

Wilson, who hits right-handed, has whacked a pair of house runs — one in his house Sacramento bandbox, and the opposite in Denver’s mile-high bandbox. It’s untimely to anticipate this energy tempo to proceed, however are you able to think about if some semblance of it does? Wilson is among the many most-added hitters in ESPN factors leagues — and he needs to be, for his profile works nicely on this format. Avoiding strikeouts can overcome an absence of energy, as Arraez has confirmed. We have to see extra of this, and a few changes, too, as a 56.5% floor ball price with out blazing velocity (or, actually, even with it) is a problem to beat. Arraez has by no means completed a season with a 50% floor ball price, although he not often hits baseballs exhausting. As with Wooden, Wilson has some changes to make, however not many. A major points-league choice stays available.

Do not be shocked … if Texas Rangers 2B Marcus Semien leads the most-dropped checklist quickly

I do not like overreacting to tough begins, particularly with regards to confirmed, veteran performers. Final week, I communicated some delicate concern in regards to the early historic strikeout begin for Boston Pink Sox 3B Rafael Devers, after which — after all — he roundly destroyed St. Louis Cardinals right-handed pitching over one weekend and that sizzling take invited nothing however ridicule. Let’s be affected person and see what we now have in a couple of months earlier than announcing Devers as both the identical top-20 hitter he has at all times been or somebody who struggles to hit .250. We now have time.

Semien, nonetheless, is six years older than Devers, and he is not coming off one other of his glorious seasons. Semien hit simply .237 with a .699 OPS final season, including solely 23 house runs and single-digit stolen bases. We crave sturdiness, however maybe by no means lacking a recreation has develop into an issue at age 34. The Rangers claimed they wished to offer Semien extra break day this season, and maybe they are going to. By 13 video games and 53 PA, nonetheless, Semien is hitting a tragic .122 with an inflated floor ball price. On this case, it seems to be the correct time to panic.

It’s exhausting to not discover what number of Rangers hitters are among the many leaders (trailers?) in BABIP. The group mark is .230, worst within the sport. Semien must make extra contact, however he is not going to complete 2025 hitting .122, both. Maybe Rangers supervisor Bruce Bochy would by no means dream of eradicating him from the leadoff spot, however Semien produced an OBP decrease than .310 in two of the previous three seasons. Then once more, maybe Bochy does not have many choices. No AL group has a decrease OBP than the Rangers at .269.

Maybe it is not even value BABIP after two weeks, so let’s not panic that 1B/3B Jake Burger, DH Joc Pederson, Semien and OF Adolis Garcia have all been fairly unfortunate thus far, with BABIPs on the fallacious facet of .175. Globe Life Discipline is a famend pitcher’s park, however the group has additionally performed in Cincinnati and Chicago (NL) thus far. The Rangers are struggling to attain runs. Getting the outdated Semien again would assist, however it’s honest to surprise if that’s asking for an excessive amount of.